Rivervale
4.6
155 Google Reviews

SMART HASHTAG 1 SPECIAL EDITIONS

200kW Launch Edition 66kWh 5dr Auto

Gearbox Automatic
Fuel Type Electric
Top Speed 112mph
Co2 0.00g/km
0 - 62mph 6.70s
No. of Seats 5

Fetching your price

Customise Your Lease

Optional Extras

Exterior Features

Paintwork

Trim

Deal Summary

200kW Launch Edition 66kWh 5dr Auto SMART HASHTAG 1 SPECIAL EDITIONS
Contract type
Contract Term
Initial Rental
Annual Mileage
Maintenance
Additional extras

Key Information

Transmission
Gearbox Automatic
Fuel Type
Fuel Type Electric
Top Speed
Top Speed 112mph
Emissions
Co2 0.00g/km
Stopwatch
0 - 62mph 6.70s
No. of Seats
No. of Seats 5

SMART HASHTAG 1 Review

The smart brand gets serious with this small electrically-powered SUV, the smart #1. Jonathan Crouch drives it.

Ten Second Review

The smart #1 reinvents the smart brand for a new era, a compact full-electric small hatch for style-conscious folk who'll enjoy a rather unique Sino-Teutonic blend of EV engineering. The car 'retains the smart spirit' but offers it in a car family fashionistas could realistically justify, with space for five and a range of up to 273 miles.

Background

Think of smart and you picture a tiny city car. But things are changing. The company is reinventing its profile as a style-led electric mobility brand and that will start with this car, the smart #1. It is, according to its maker, 'the nucleus of all things to come'. Which means several things. First, that in the future, we'll see bigger smart models than we've been used to - this #1 is a small SUV about the size of a Kia Niro or a MINI Countryman. And second that while the design of future smart models will still be over-seen by parent company Mercedes (hence, for instance, the #1's EQ-style rear light cluster), platforms for the company's cars will in future be provided by the Chinese automotive group Geely, who now hold 50% shareholding in smart. In this case, that means Geely's 'SEA' 'Sustainable Experience Architecture' platform, a chassis also earmarked for a forthcoming compact crossover from Volvo. Big departures then. The smart brand's first SUV, its first five-seater, it's first larger car. What's in store?

Driving Experience

The electric powertrain here sees a 66kWh nickel-manganese-cobalt battery power a rear-mounted motor putting out 268hp and 343Nm of pulling power, which should be enough for agile performance, despite the hefty 1,820kg kerb weight; expect rest to 62mph to take just 6.7s and smart has limited top speed to 112mph. Driving range is rated at 260 miles for the 'Pro+', 273 miles for the 'Premium' and 248 miles for the 'BRABUS'. Larger battery sizes are being considered - and smaller ones too - in a bid to make future entry-level variants more affordable. At the top of the range is a 4WD Dual Motor BRABUS version with 422hp and 543Nm of torque. Paired with a specifically calibrated BRABUS driving mode, this results in a rapid 0-62mph performance of just 3.9 seconds. For most customers though, the smart #1 will be 2WD and, as usual with an EV, whisper-quiet. The advanced 'SEA' Geely-sourced platform should provide for taut handling and a supple ride. And smart is providing a range of autonomous driving tools, including Adaptive Cruise Control with stop and go, Lane keep assist, Blind Spot Monitoring, Highway and Traffic Jam Assist.

Design and Build

The look of this smart #1 gives us a clue to what future smart models will look like. This one's a small SUV and Mercedes-Benz Chief Designer Gorden Wagener, who oversaw the styling describes it as 'cool, fresh and enchanting'; you decide. The shape is characterised by smooth surfaces, a so-called 'flying' roof, a two-tone paint scheme and a sleek design that flows down over the C-pillars. The simple lighting signatures clearly reference Mercedes EQ designs like the EQA, particularly at the rear. And the wrap-around front light bar incorporates full-LED headlamps as standard. Early variants get large 19-inch wheels too. Emphasising the kind of size that's significantly larger than anything the brand has delivered before; this car is 4,270mm in length. You enter via concealed door handles. In the minimalist cabin, the fascia's dominated by a 12.8-inch touchscreen which uses an AI-based infotainment system with a 3D interface and over-the-air updates. This is further supported by a 9.2-inch HD digital instrument screen and the option of a 10-inch Head-up display. You can have a novel 'halo' roof, which lightens up the interior. And a 13-speaker Dr Dre Beats audio upgrade will be offered. Out back, thanks to the lengthy 4,027mm wheelbase, there's apparently more room than you'd get in a Mercedes E-Class executive saloon. And you get a decently-sized 411-litre boot (421-litres in the 'Pro+').

Market and Model

This will be easily the most expensive smart model ever made. The brand says that it wants to pitch this model against cars like Volkswagen's ID 3, which means that you can expect a starting price of around £32,000. Other target models include fashion-led small SUVs like the Kia Niro and the DS 3. Smart doesn't have any solus UK dealerships. There are currently around 35 Mercedes-Benz franchises in the UK that also sell smart models, where the brand occupies its own separate space in the showroom with a dedicated smart sales person on hand. The line-up starts with the base 'Pro' model. Next up in the main range, there are 'Pro+' versions (from around £36,000), 'Premium' variants (from around £39,000) and 'BRABUS' models (from around £43,500). On all smart #1 variants, as standard, there's lots of media connectivity, courtesy of a central 12.8-inch touchscreen which is fully customisable and provides an interface for an avatar that responds to speech commands - from launch a fox, but other characters will be added. There's also a 9.2-inch full HD digital instrument binnacle. Top models get a Head-up display; and an innovative 'Halo roof' which makes the interior feel airy and spacious. Safety provision include seven airbags. And you can also specify an 'Advanced Driver Assistance' system package, which gives Adaptive Cruise Control with stop and go, Lane keep assist, Blind Spot Monitoring, Highway and Traffic Jam Assist, Adaptive High Beam headlights and automatic parking.

Cost of Ownership

The smart brand will start to sell this car with a 66kWh battery offering a range of up to 273 miles - that's for the mid-range 'Premium' version. The base 'Pro+' model manages 260 miles and the top 4WD 'BRABUS' variant manages 248 miles. Other battery options are expected to be added to the range in due course. Thanks to the car's 150kW rapid charge capability, the 66kWh battery can be topped up from 10 to 80% in under 30 minutes. Connect up to a 22kW AC charger and a 10-80% charge takes around three hours. Range is maximised by the car's slippery shape - there's a sleek drag co-efficient of 0.29Cd, achieved thanks also to features like an active grille shutter and concealed door handles. The other things you need to know are exactly the same as is the case with any other smart model. There's a three-year unlimited mileage warranty, plus you get 'smart move assist', an included twelve-month international roadside assistance package that can be renewed annually following a smart dealer service.

Summary

It's taken smart nearly three decades to come up with a car it might profitably sell in serious numbers in a mainstream market segment. Finally though, that's with what we've got with the #1, the first new model from the brand since 2014. It enters an increasingly crowded segment, but it's certainly different - and potentially very individual. In that sense, the #1 very much retains a smart spirit, as does the funky cabin. What isn't very smart is the asking price, way above anything brand loyalists have had to find in the past. But this is a very different kind of car, catering for the completely different kind of audience this re-invented brand is now seeking. The smart brand has grown up. #about time.

Data provided by CAP-HPI database - Ref# 103160

Vehicle Review

Standard Equipment

Technical Data

The smart brand gets serious with this small electrically-powered SUV, the smart #1. Jonathan Crouch drives it.

Ten Second Review

The smart #1 reinvents the smart brand for a new era, a compact full-electric small hatch for style-conscious folk who'll enjoy a rather unique Sino-Teutonic blend of EV engineering. The car 'retains the smart spirit' but offers it in a car family fashionistas could realistically justify, with space for five and a range of up to 273 miles.

Background

Think of smart and you picture a tiny city car. But things are changing. The company is reinventing its profile as a style-led electric mobility brand and that will start with this car, the smart #1. It is, according to its maker, 'the nucleus of all things to come'. Which means several things. First, that in the future, we'll see bigger smart models than we've been used to - this #1 is a small SUV about the size of a Kia Niro or a MINI Countryman. And second that while the design of future smart models will still be over-seen by parent company Mercedes (hence, for instance, the #1's EQ-style rear light cluster), platforms for the company's cars will in future be provided by the Chinese automotive group Geely, who now hold 50% shareholding in smart. In this case, that means Geely's 'SEA' 'Sustainable Experience Architecture' platform, a chassis also earmarked for a forthcoming compact crossover from Volvo. Big departures then. The smart brand's first SUV, its first five-seater, it's first larger car. What's in store?

Driving Experience

The electric powertrain here sees a 66kWh nickel-manganese-cobalt battery power a rear-mounted motor putting out 268hp and 343Nm of pulling power, which should be enough for agile performance, despite the hefty 1,820kg kerb weight; expect rest to 62mph to take just 6.7s and smart has limited top speed to 112mph. Driving range is rated at 260 miles for the 'Pro+', 273 miles for the 'Premium' and 248 miles for the 'BRABUS'. Larger battery sizes are being considered - and smaller ones too - in a bid to make future entry-level variants more affordable. At the top of the range is a 4WD Dual Motor BRABUS version with 422hp and 543Nm of torque. Paired with a specifically calibrated BRABUS driving mode, this results in a rapid 0-62mph performance of just 3.9 seconds. For most customers though, the smart #1 will be 2WD and, as usual with an EV, whisper-quiet. The advanced 'SEA' Geely-sourced platform should provide for taut handling and a supple ride. And smart is providing a range of autonomous driving tools, including Adaptive Cruise Control with stop and go, Lane keep assist, Blind Spot Monitoring, Highway and Traffic Jam Assist.

Design and Build

The look of this smart #1 gives us a clue to what future smart models will look like. This one's a small SUV and Mercedes-Benz Chief Designer Gorden Wagener, who oversaw the styling describes it as 'cool, fresh and enchanting'; you decide. The shape is characterised by smooth surfaces, a so-called 'flying' roof, a two-tone paint scheme and a sleek design that flows down over the C-pillars. The simple lighting signatures clearly reference Mercedes EQ designs like the EQA, particularly at the rear. And the wrap-around front light bar incorporates full-LED headlamps as standard. Early variants get large 19-inch wheels too. Emphasising the kind of size that's significantly larger than anything the brand has delivered before; this car is 4,270mm in length. You enter via concealed door handles. In the minimalist cabin, the fascia's dominated by a 12.8-inch touchscreen which uses an AI-based infotainment system with a 3D interface and over-the-air updates. This is further supported by a 9.2-inch HD digital instrument screen and the option of a 10-inch Head-up display. You can have a novel 'halo' roof, which lightens up the interior. And a 13-speaker Dr Dre Beats audio upgrade will be offered. Out back, thanks to the lengthy 4,027mm wheelbase, there's apparently more room than you'd get in a Mercedes E-Class executive saloon. And you get a decently-sized 411-litre boot (421-litres in the 'Pro+').

Market and Model

This will be easily the most expensive smart model ever made. The brand says that it wants to pitch this model against cars like Volkswagen's ID 3, which means that you can expect a starting price of around £32,000. Other target models include fashion-led small SUVs like the Kia Niro and the DS 3. Smart doesn't have any solus UK dealerships. There are currently around 35 Mercedes-Benz franchises in the UK that also sell smart models, where the brand occupies its own separate space in the showroom with a dedicated smart sales person on hand. The line-up starts with the base 'Pro' model. Next up in the main range, there are 'Pro+' versions (from around £36,000), 'Premium' variants (from around £39,000) and 'BRABUS' models (from around £43,500). On all smart #1 variants, as standard, there's lots of media connectivity, courtesy of a central 12.8-inch touchscreen which is fully customisable and provides an interface for an avatar that responds to speech commands - from launch a fox, but other characters will be added. There's also a 9.2-inch full HD digital instrument binnacle. Top models get a Head-up display; and an innovative 'Halo roof' which makes the interior feel airy and spacious. Safety provision include seven airbags. And you can also specify an 'Advanced Driver Assistance' system package, which gives Adaptive Cruise Control with stop and go, Lane keep assist, Blind Spot Monitoring, Highway and Traffic Jam Assist, Adaptive High Beam headlights and automatic parking.

Cost of Ownership

The smart brand will start to sell this car with a 66kWh battery offering a range of up to 273 miles - that's for the mid-range 'Premium' version. The base 'Pro+' model manages 260 miles and the top 4WD 'BRABUS' variant manages 248 miles. Other battery options are expected to be added to the range in due course. Thanks to the car's 150kW rapid charge capability, the 66kWh battery can be topped up from 10 to 80% in under 30 minutes. Connect up to a 22kW AC charger and a 10-80% charge takes around three hours. Range is maximised by the car's slippery shape - there's a sleek drag co-efficient of 0.29Cd, achieved thanks also to features like an active grille shutter and concealed door handles. The other things you need to know are exactly the same as is the case with any other smart model. There's a three-year unlimited mileage warranty, plus you get 'smart move assist', an included twelve-month international roadside assistance package that can be renewed annually following a smart dealer service.

Summary

It's taken smart nearly three decades to come up with a car it might profitably sell in serious numbers in a mainstream market segment. Finally though, that's with what we've got with the #1, the first new model from the brand since 2014. It enters an increasingly crowded segment, but it's certainly different - and potentially very individual. In that sense, the #1 very much retains a smart spirit, as does the funky cabin. What isn't very smart is the asking price, way above anything brand loyalists have had to find in the past. But this is a very different kind of car, catering for the completely different kind of audience this re-invented brand is now seeking. The smart brand has grown up. #about time.

Driver Convenience

  • 10" head-up display
  • 12 front and rear parking sensors
  • 12.8" central display screen
  • 360 degree view camera
  • 3D connected navigation + voice control
  • 9.2" HD instrument cluster
  • Active lane keep assist
  • Adaptive cruise control with Stop and Go
  • Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
  • Automatic parking assist
  • Bcall
  • Blind spot detection
  • Bluetooth
  • Drive mode inc. ECO, Comfort and Sport
  • Driver monitoring system
  • Electrical power assist steering
  • Emergency call service
  • Emergency lane keep assist+
  • Evasive manoeuvre support
  • Front Cross Traffic Alert
  • Gesture tailgate
  • Intelligent speed assist
  • Lane change assist
  • Lane departure system
  • Lane departure warning
  • Rear cross traffic alert
  • Remote control release for trunk/rear door
  • Smart pilot assist
  • Telematics
  • TFT display screen
  • Traffic jam assist
  • Traffic sign recognition
  • Trip computer
  • Wireless device charging

Engine/Drivetrain/Suspension

  • 22kW AC Charging
  • 22kW onboard charger
  • Comfort suspension
  • e-Pedal

Entertainment

  • 13 speakers
  • 4 USB ports
  • Audio system with 5 speakers
  • Beats audio system
  • DAB audio
  • Remote audio control

Exterior Features

  • 2 x One touch front electric windows
  • 2 x One touch rear electric windows
  • Active grille shutters
  • Adaptive high beam assist
  • Auto dimming door mirrors
  • Auto dimming interior mirror
  • Courtesy lights with logo projection
  • CyberSparks LED+ Matrix headlights
  • Dynamic indicators
  • Electric halo roof blind
  • Electrically adjustable, heated door mirrors with memory and reverse auto-dipping
  • Frameless Doors
  • Front intermittent wipers
  • Frunk
  • Halo panoramic roof printing
  • Halo panoramic sunroof
  • Headlight control with dusk sensor
  • Illuminated concealed door handles
  • Intermittent rear wiper
  • LED brake lights
  • LED daytime running lights
  • LED low and high beam headlights
  • LED rear lights
  • LED tail lamp
  • Metallic paint
  • Painted door mirrors
  • Rain sensing windscreen wipers
  • Rear door lifting gate
  • Rear side wing doors
  • Roof rails
  • Side window and rear windshield privacy glass
  • Third brake light featuring LED technology
  • Trailer stability assist

Interior Features

  • 2 zone automatic air conditioning
  • 3 seat rear bench
  • 6 Way powered driver and passenger seat adjustment with lumbar support
  • 60/40 split rear seats
  • Air filter+
  • Air quality system
  • Ambient lighting+
  • Center console with air vent cooling
  • Centre console cup holders
  • Driver memory seat
  • Duo leather upholstery
  • Easy entry and exit seat adjustment
  • Electric reclining passenger seat
  • Front and rear head restraints
  • Front and trunk 12V port
  • Front passenger seat ISOFIX
  • Front seat centre armrests
  • Heat pump
  • Heated driver and passenger seats
  • Illuminated passenger vanity mirror
  • Illuminated stainless steel tread plates
  • Isofix rear child seat preparation
  • Loadspace cover
  • Manually adjustable steering column
  • Multi function steering wheel
  • Overhead console glasses storage
  • Perforated leather steering wheel
  • PM2.5 sensor
  • Reading lights
  • Rear air vents on center console
  • Rear centre armrest with cup holders
  • Rear seat angle adjustment
  • Rear seat load-through access
  • Single front passenger seat
  • Sliding rear seats
  • Tilt/telescopic adjustable steering wheel

Passive Safety

  • 3x3 point rear seat belts
  • Airbags - driver and front passenger
  • Anti-lock braking system (ABS)
  • Anti-Roll system
  • Autohold
  • BAS (Brake Assist System)
  • Child locks on rear doors
  • Cornering brake control
  • Door open warning
  • Driver and passenger front seat belt pre tensioners
  • Electric parking brake
  • Electrically operated hand brake
  • Electronic brake distribution
  • Electronic traction control
  • Emergency brake assist
  • First aid kit
  • Front + rear side airbags
  • Front and rear collision mitigation
  • Front central airbag
  • Front seat belt height adjustment
  • Hill descent control
  • Hill start assist
  • Parking emergency brake
  • Regenerative braking system
  • Roll stability control
  • Safety vest
  • Side curtain airbags
  • Tyre pressure monitoring system
  • Ventilated disc brakes
  • Warning triangle

Security

  • 2 keyfobs
  • Anti theft alarm
  • Anti theft immobiliser
  • Anti theft internal monitor
  • Anti theft steering wheel lock
  • Keyless entry
  • Power door locks
  • Remote door locking and unlocking
  • Smart card/smart key includes central locking

Trim

  • Man made leather wrapped instrument panel

Wheels

  • 19" Prism alloy wheels
  • Summer tyres
  • Tyre repair kit

Electric Vehicle Data

  • Battery Capacity % guaranteed under warranty
    70
  • Battery Capacity in kWh
    66
  • Battery Charging Scenario 1 - Charge Time (Mins)
    180
  • Battery Charging Scenario 1 - Percentage Change
    10-80
  • Battery Charging Scenario 1 - Power Supply - kW
    22
  • Battery Charging Scenario 2 - Charge Time (Mins)
    30
  • Battery Charging Scenario 2 - Percentage Change
    10-80
  • Battery Charging Scenario 2 - Power Supply - kW
    150
  • Battery Charging Scenario 3 - Charge Time (Mins)
    Not Available
  • Battery Charging Scenario 3 - Percentage Change
    Not Available
  • Battery Charging Scenario 3 - Power Supply - kW
    Not Available
  • Battery Charging Scenario 4 - Charge Time (Mins)
    Not Available
  • Battery Charging Scenario 4 - Percentage Change
    Not Available
  • Battery Charging Scenario 4 - Power Supply - kW
    Not Available
  • Battery Leased
    No
  • Battery Type
    Lithium-ion
  • Charging Port Location
    Right Side Rear
  • Coupler/Connector Type
    CCS Type 2
  • Maximum Charging Rate - kW
    150
  • Standard manufacturers Battery warranty - Mileage
    200000
  • Standard manufacturers Battery warranty - Years
    8
  • Usable Battery Capacity
    62
  • WLTP - EC (kWh/100km) - Comb
    16.8
  • WLTP - EC (miles/kWh) - Comb
    3.7
  • WLTP - Pure Electric Range (km) - City
    597
  • WLTP - Pure Electric Range (km) - Comb
    439
  • WLTP - Pure Electric Range (miles) - City
    371
  • WLTP - Pure Electric Range (miles) - Comb
    273

Emissions - ICE

  • CO
    Not Available
  • CO2 (g/km)
    0
  • HC
    Not Available
  • HC+NOx
    Not Available
  • NOx
    Not Available
  • Particles
    Not Available
  • Standard Emissions
    Not Available

Engine and Drive Train

  • Camshaft
    Not Available
  • Catalytic Convertor
    No
  • CC
    1
  • Compression Ratio
    Not Available
  • Cylinder Layout
    Not Available
  • Cylinders
    Not Available
  • Cylinders - Bore (mm)
    Not Available
  • Cylinders - Stroke (mm)
    Not Available
  • Engine Code
    Not Available
  • Engine Layout
    Not Available
  • Fuel Delivery
    Not Available
  • Gears
    1 SPEED
  • Number of Valves
    Not Available
  • Transmission
    AUTO

Fuel Consumption - ICE

  • EC Combined (mpg)
    Not Available
  • EC Directive 1999/100/EC Applies
    Not Available
  • EC Extra Urban (mpg)
    Not Available
  • EC Urban (mpg)
    Not Available

General

  • Alternative Fuel Qualifying
    Yes
  • Badge Engine CC
  • Badge Power
    200
  • Based On ID
    103076
  • Coin Description
    200kW 66kWh
  • Coin Series
    Launch Edition
  • Generation Mark
    1
  • Insurance Group 1 - 50 Effective January 07
    32E
  • Manufacturers Corrosion Perforation Guarantee - Years
    12
  • Manufacturers Paintwork Guarantee - Years
    3
  • NCAP Adult Occupant Protection %
    96
  • NCAP Child Occupant Protection %
    89
  • NCAP Overall Rating - Effective February 09
    5
  • NCAP Pedestrian Protection %
    71
  • NCAP Safety Assist %
    88
  • Did at least one aspect of this vehicle's safety give cause for concern?
    No
  • Service Interval Frequency - Months
    24
  • Service Interval Mileage
    20000
  • Special Edition
    Yes
  • Special Order
    No
  • Standard manufacturers warranty - Mileage
    Unlimited
  • Standard manufacturers warranty - Years
    3
  • Timing Belt Interval Frequency - Months
    Not Available
  • Timing Belt Interval Mileage
    Not Available
  • Vehicle Homologation Class
    M1

Performance

  • 0 to 62 mph (secs)
    6.7
  • Engine Power - BHP
    272
  • Engine Power - KW
    200
  • Engine Power - RPM
    5500
  • Engine Torque - LBS.FT
    253
  • Engine Torque - MKG
    35
  • Engine Torque - NM
    343
  • Engine Torque - RPM
    300
  • Top Speed
    112

Test Cycles

  • Emissions Test Cycle
    WLTP
  • RDE Certification Level
    N/A

Tyres

  • Alloys?
    Yes
  • Space Saver?
    No
  • Tyre Size Front
    235/45 R19
  • Tyre Size Rear
    235/45 R19
  • Tyre Size Spare
    TYRE REPAIR KIT
  • Wheel Style
    PRISM
  • Wheel Type
    19" ALLOY

Vehicle Dimensions

  • Height
    1636
  • Height (including roof rails)
    Not Available
  • Length
    4270
  • Wheelbase
    2750
  • Width
    1822
  • Width (including mirrors)
    1924

Weight and Capacities

  • Fuel Tank Capacity (Litres)
    Not Available
  • Gross Vehicle Weight
    2225
  • Luggage Capacity (Seats Down)
    976
  • Luggage Capacity (Seats Up)
    313
  • Max. Loading Weight
    425
  • Max. Roof Load
    50
  • Max. Towing Weight - Braked
    1600
  • Max. Towing Weight - Unbraked
    750
  • Minimum Kerbweight
    1800
  • No. of Seats
    5

You May Also Like...

Electric

NISSAN ARIYA

160kW Advance 63kWh 5dr Auto

Transmission
Automatic
Fuel Type
Electric
Battery Size
63kWh

POA

Business Lease Price per month (excl VAT) £333.90

  • 60 months
  • 5000 miles/year
  • £4,006.80 Initial Rental
Electric

MG MOTOR UK MG4

150kW Trophy EV Long Range 64kWh 5dr Auto

Transmission
Automatic
Fuel Type
Electric
Battery Size
64kWh

POA

Business Lease Price per month (excl VAT) £440.66

  • 48 months
  • 6000 miles/year
  • £5,287.92 Initial Rental
Electric

RENAULT 4

110kW Techno+ 52kWh Comfort range 5dr Auto[Canvas]

Transmission
Automatic
Fuel Type
Electric
Battery Size
52kWh

POA

Business Lease Price per month (excl VAT) £231.68

  • 48 months
  • 6000 miles/year
  • £2,780.16 Initial Rental
Electric

BYD DOLPHIN SURF

65kW Active 30kWh 5dr Auto

Transmission
Automatic
Fuel Type
Electric
Battery Size
30kWh

POA

POA

Back to top

Need help choosing the right deal?